Skip to content
Legal & Courts

Chris Brown Housekeeper Accepts Reduced $9.5M Dog-Attack Award

Share this storyFacebookXEmail
A Caucasian Shepherd dog in a forest; illustrative breed photo, not the dog involved in the case.
Image source: Wikimedia Commons; photographer/uploader: NinjaRobotPirate

Maria Avila, the former housekeeper who won a multimillion-dollar jury verdict after being injured by a dog at Chris Brown’s Tarzana home, has accepted a reduced $9.5 million damages award rather than retry the damages phase of the case.

The jury originally awarded nearly $12.9 million

A Los Angeles County jury found Brown and his company, Black Pyramid LLC, liable in connection with the 2020 dog attack and awarded Avila nearly $12.9 million in damages.

Avila alleged that she suffered serious physical and emotional injuries while working at Brown’s property.

The judge found the original award excessive

Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Huey P. Cotton later ruled that the evidence did not support the full amount awarded by the jury for claimed permanent nerve damage and future pain and suffering.

The judge conditionally granted Brown a new trial on damages for Avila alone unless she accepted a reduced award of $9.5 million.

Avila chose the reduced award

Avila filed notice accepting the $9.5 million figure. That decision avoids a new trial limited to the amount of damages.

Reporting on the filing says the reduced award includes compensation for past and future non-economic losses and future medical expenses.

Liability was not overturned

The court’s order addressed the size of Avila’s damages award, not the underlying liability determination. The jury’s finding against Brown and Black Pyramid was not erased by the reduction.

That distinction matters: a remittitur, or court-ordered reduction offered as an alternative to a new damages trial, does not necessarily disturb the jury’s conclusion about who was legally responsible.

Where the case stands

By accepting the reduced award, Avila avoided the risk and expense of retrying damages. The publicly reported dispute at this stage therefore centers on enforcement and any remaining post-trial or appellate issues rather than a new damages trial.

Sources

Reporting & source note
Aggregated With Analysis
Source: Los Angeles Times

About the author

Eli Mercer

Hollywood Most Wanted house byline for courts, legal affairs and investigations. Eli Mercer is an editorial pen name used by HMW, not a separate real-world staff biography.

More from this author →